This Bee-Killing Pesticide May Be in Your Flowers
Many of the plants we buy from the nursery or garden center have been grown with a pesticide in them. This is to keep the plants free of pests during their growing and in the retail markets, so we can plant pest-free plants at our homes.
This pesticide is a class of pesticides called neonicitioids, or neonics for short. It’s a nicotine-based chemical that affects the nervous system of pests. It’s usually used systemically so that it travels throughout the entire plant to kill pests that suck on foliage; pests like aphids, certain scales, whiteflies, flea beetles, etc.
But, the pesticide accumulates in the nectar and pollen of the plants’ flowers. To make matters worse, it remains in the plant for many months and even years.
This means bees and other pollinators ingest this pesticide. It doesn’t kill them outright but it’s been shown to affect their cognitive abilities, communication, and navigation skills, which impairs their ability to gather food for their young.
On this page
Why are they used?
Neonics were developed as a pesticide with lower toxicity to humans than organophosphates, which they replace. Testing was done to determine their safety to humans and small mammals. They were approved for use in 1994 and quickly became the most used pesticide in the world.
They’re used as a preventative pesticide, so they’re used before any problem arises, and used in all the plants. They’re applied systemically as a soil drench or as a seed coat that infuses it into the plant as it germinates and grows. They’re now used on most crops!
But the research did not look closely at the impacts to the bees.
“The motivation for producing neonicotinoids was reduced human toxicity, but the environmental and ecosystem impacts were not considered in enough detail to predict what’s going on,” James Frazier, professor of entomology at Pennsylvania State University in an article in YaleEnvironment360, by Elizabeth Grossman, 2013
Effects on bees
Many studies show that neonics have a ‘sublethal’ effect on bees. They’re not killed outright but they experience the effects mentioned above which impairs food gathering abilities, lowers production of offspring, and reduces ability to resist pests and diseases.
Native bees, like bumble bees and other small bees, are thought to be more vulnerable than honeybees. And not much research has been done on them yet.
Effects on beneficial insects
Beneficial insects are the insects that prey on “pest” insects—the ones they’re trying to get rid of with the neonics. But some pest insects are becoming resistant to the neonics. Those pest insects concentrate the neonics and pass it to their predators, harming them—a lose-lose situation! More, the aphids secrete honeydew which attracts the beneficial insects and is contaminated with the neonic chemical, again, harming important beneficial insects.
Effects on birds
A Canadian study was done to determine effects of neonics on white-crowned sparrows. The sparrows were fed only 1% of what birds may normally find in agricultural fields. The results were rapid weight loss and delayed and impaired migration. Again, this was sublethal effects but effects that impaired well-being and reproduction abilities.
It has been found that one corn neonic coated corn seed can kill a songbird. Migrating birds use agricultural fields as a major source of food.
They end up in soil, non-target plants, and waterways
Being used as a soil drench or as a seed coating, puts the chemical in the soil. This can kill soil organisms, even the soil organisms that create healthy soil and feed plants.
Any plants near the treated plant get the neonic in it, too. The roots pick it up.
Neonics can end up in waterways and have even been found in puddles.
The US Geological Survey has been researching the presence of neonics in runoff water from farm operations because neonic’s use as a seed coating has become so pervasive over the past decade. The concern is the impact to water systems and the animals they support.
Home use of neonics is worse
In the hands of homeowners, it’s likely neonic products get overused and improperly used. Farmers and grower nurseries use trained pesticide applicators who abide by laws and recommendations for treatments.
But home users can use 12 to 16 times the amount allowed in agricultural use, sometimes even more. Residue levels in some ornamental plants exceed lethal levels to honeybees and bumble bees.
The most commonly used neonics are Imidacloprid, Clothiandin, Thiamethoxam, Acetamiprid, and thiacloprid. They’re in a variety of products and are used as systemic treatments for trees, roses, and other landscape plants, promising to eliminate pest problems.
Look at the ingredients of the products you may use. Don’t use it if you see one of the above chemicals on the ingredients list. If it’s a systemic treatment, it’s particularly suspect. Choose a product that’s OMRI Listed instead. This means the product has been approved as an organic solution to a problem.
Or instead, try to be patient and let your beneficial insect population catch up with your pest insects. Sometimes it takes a little while. If we kill the beneficial insects along with the pests, we will be fighting the same problem over and over. But if we allow and encourage the beneficials to do their work, they’ll be better able to keep our gardens in a good pest-predator balance.
What to do about it
Most bedding plants are not treated with neonoics. But trees, shrubs, and perennial flowers most likely are if they’re not from a neonic-free source.
Look for plants, seeds, and bulbs that are labelled ‘neonic-free’. Some growers make the statement on their websites, instead. Buying organic is safe.
If you can’t find retail sources of neonic-free plants, let your nursery or garden center know that is what you want. The Xerces Society has a PDF to print and hand to your nursery to let them know that it’s important to you. (They have lots of information on how you can help bees and other pollinators. Check out their website, xerces.org.
Many big box garden centers have eliminated neonic-laden plants from their offerings. Lowe’s, Home Depot, Ace Hardware, and many others have phased out the use of neonics in their plants. And many have phased out neonic garden products.
If you need to buy plants that are not neonic-free, one suggestion is putting a mesh bag or row cover type fabric (Agribon or similar) over the plant when it flowers the first year, to keep pollinators off it.
Or you can cut off the flowers for the first year (you may be able to use them in your home!). After a year the amount of neonic in the plant will be greatly reduced.
How Neonics Can Kill Bees Xerces Society
Declining Bee Populations Pose a Threat to Global Agriculture YaleEnvironment360
Neonicotinoid Treatment Study US Geological Survey
Neonicotinoids: What Gardeners Need to Know Treehugger